Skip to main content

Table 2 Patient-related outcome measures at pre-operative and 2-year follow-up evaluation, and the inter-group comparison

From: Role of debulking mucoid ACL in unicompartmental knee arthroplasty: a prospective multicentric study

 

Debulking group (n = 226)

No debulking group (n = 216)

Inter-group comparison (Mann–Whitney U test)

 

Mean

SD

Mean

SD

Z-value

p-Value

Knee Society score

 Pre-operative

55.642

3.457

56.335

3.24

1.11

0.1

 2-year follow-up

93.60

3.182

87.25

5.488

12.339

0.000

IKDC

 Pre-operative

48.26

2.892

48.981

3.17

1.08

0.11

 2-year follow-up

82.49

2.649

78.52

4.979

8.86

0.000

Flexion (degrees)

 Pre-operative

96.385

5.779

98.09

4.79

2.773

0.06

 2-year follow-up

117.89

2.644

103.11

4.096

18.219

0.000

Patient satisfaction

 2-year follow-up

9.832

0.375

8.676

0.707

16.083

0.000

VAS Score for rest pain

      

 2-year follow-up

0.13

0.462

2.64

0.954

18.761

0.000

Lachman’s test (number of knees)

 Intra-operative

Stable: 199

1A*: 27

 2-year follow-up

Stable: 201

1A*: 25

  1. Boldface indicates statistical significance (p < 0.05)
  2. IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee, ROM range of motion, VAS visual analogue scale; SD standard deviation
  3. *1A: Less than 5 mm Anteroposterior translation with a firm end point