Parameters | Same-stage, bilateral TKR (n = 95) | Two-stage, bilateral TKR (n = 80) | P |
---|---|---|---|
Demographics | |||
Age (years) | 65.6 (51–77, SD 5.31) | 68.7 (56–79, SD 6.46) | 0.041 |
Gender | 26 M, 69 F | 22 M, 58 F | 0.894 |
ASA grade | 1: 5, 5.26%, | 1: 3, 3.75% | < 0.001 |
2: 90, 94.74% | 2: 54, 67.97%, | ||
3: 0% | 3: 24, 30.07% | ||
Implant choice | Triathlon 124 (65.3%) Attune 66 (34.7%) | Triathlon 112 (70.0%) Attune 48 (30.0%) | 0.505 |
Pre-operation function | |||
FS | 50.2 (5–80, SD 13.19, | 47.3 (5–90, SD 16.00, | 0.706 |
95% CI 47.7–52.9) | 95% CI 43.8–50.8) | ||
KS | 44.3 (18–79, SD 13.54, | 44.5 (12–77, SD 12.82, | 0.025 |
95% CI 41.6–47) | 95% CI 41.7–47.3) | ||
OKS | 24.9 (8–54, SD 6.69, | 25.2 (6–54, SD 7.62, | 0.855 |
95% CI 23.5–26.3) | 95% CI 23.5–26.9) | ||
Cost-effectiveness | |||
LOS (days) | 6.64 (3–12, SD 2.14, | 12.35a (7–65, SD 6.67, | < 0.001 |
95% CI 6.21–7.07) | 95% CI 10.9–13.8) | ||
6.07b (2–43) | < 0.001 | ||
OTTc (mins) for 2 knees | 152.8c (68–478, SD 31.34, | 180.3c (111–417c, SD 48.46, | < 0.001 |
95% CI 147.1–159.2) | 95% CI 170–191) | ||
PhyS | 14.56d (3–26, SD 4.78, | 17.90d (11–37, SD 4.68, | < 0.001 |
95% CI 13.5–15.6) | 95% CI 17.0–18.8) | ||
OccS | 3.56d (2–8, SD 1.97, | 7.34d (2–24, SD 2.40, | < 0.001 |
95% CI 3.16–3.96) | 95% CI 6.81–7.87) | ||
Safety | |||
PreHb (g/dL) | 13.50 (9.8–16.6, SD 1.10, | 13.00 (9.1–15.7, SD 1.31, | 0.002 |
95% CI 13.3–13.7) | 95% CI 12.7–13.3) | ||
HbD1 (g/dL) | 10.47 (7.0–14.1, SD 1.28, | 10.93 (7.4–14.1, SD 1.43, | 0.003 |
95% CI 10.2–10.7) | 95% CI 10.6–11.2) | ||
HbDrop (g/dL) | 3.03 (0.0–6.0, SD 1.21, | 2.07 (− 0.1–6.2, SD 1.01, | < 0.001 |
95% CI 2.79–3.27) | 95% CI 1.85–2.29) | ||
Transfusion percentage | 8.42% (16 of 190 knees) | 3.75% (6 of 160 knees) | 0.078 |
TV (units) for 2 knees | 0.18 (0–6, SD 0.45, | 0.09 (0–4, SD 0.76, | 0.116 |
95% CI 0.090–0.27) | 95% CI − 0.52–0.70) | ||
SurgCR | 7.37% (7 of 95 operations) | 5.63% (9 of 160 operations) | 0.511 |
MedCR | 3.68% (7 of 190 knees) | 5.63% (9 of 160 knees) | 0.386 |
10.5% (10 of 95 operations) | 6.20% (10 of 160 operations) | 0.155 | |
RR | 3.16% (3 of 95 operation) | 4.38% (7 of 160 operations) | 0.548 |
30-days UPR | 2.11% (2 of 95 operations) | 6.92% (11 of 160 operations) | 0.094 |
90-days UPR | 4.21% (4 of 95 operations) | 9.43% (15 of 160 operations) | 0.129 |