Skip to main content

Table 3 Description of included trials: Method of Evaluation

From: Outcome Differences of Remnant- Preserving versus Non-Preserving Methods in Arthroscopic Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Meta-analysis with Subgroup analysis

Author

Stability

Pivot shift test

Lachman test

Lysholm test

IKDC grade

IKDC subjective score

Complication

KT-1000

KT-2000

Rolimeter

Cyclops lesion

MRI

Second look arthroscopy

RCT

 Gohil, et al. [10]

O

      

O

O

 

 Hong, et al. [11]

O

  

O

O

O

O

  

O

 Mohtadi, et al. [12]

O

  

O

      

 Pujol, et al. [13]

  

O

O

O

O

O

O

 

O

 Zhang, et al. [5]

 

O

   

O

    

Observation study

 Qi, et al. [14]

 

O

   

O

 

O

  

 Park, et al. [15]

O

  

O

O

O

 

O

  

 Naylor, et al. [16]

 

O

 

O

O

 

O

O

  

 Takazawa, et al. [17]

 

O

 

O

      

 Chen, et al. [18]

 

O

   

O

 

O

  

 Kondo, et al. [19]

 

O

 

O

 

O

   

O

  1. IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee, MRI Magnetic resonance imaging
Back to article page

Knee Surgery & Related Research

ISSN: 2234-2451