Skip to main content

Table 3 Description of included trials: Method of Evaluation

From: Outcome Differences of Remnant- Preserving versus Non-Preserving Methods in Arthroscopic Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Meta-analysis with Subgroup analysis

AuthorStabilityPivot shift testLachman testLysholm testIKDC gradeIKDC subjective scoreComplication
KT-1000KT-2000RolimeterCyclops lesion
MRISecond look arthroscopy
RCT
 Gohil, et al. [10]O      OO 
 Hong, et al. [11]O  OOOO  O
 Mohtadi, et al. [12]O  O      
 Pujol, et al. [13]  OOOOOO O
 Zhang, et al. [5] O   O    
Observation study
 Qi, et al. [14] O   O O  
 Park, et al. [15]O  OOO O  
 Naylor, et al. [16] O OO OO  
 Takazawa, et al. [17] O O      
 Chen, et al. [18] O   O O  
 Kondo, et al. [19] O O O   O
  1. IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee, MRI Magnetic resonance imaging