Skip to main content

Table 2 Current reports on outcome of two-stage revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

From: Two-stage revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction

Year Author Level of study Country No. of case Mean age (years) Bone graft Mean F/U Outcomes
2005 Thomas et al. III United Kingdom 49 35.4 Iliac autobone 6.2 years IKDC: 61.2, Objective laxity: 1.36 mm
2013 Franceschi et al. IV Italy 30 29.1 Proximal tibia autobone 6.7 years Lysholm: 90.2, return to sports: 66.7%
2016 Uchida et al. IV Japan 10 28.0 Iliac autobone Minimum 2 years Negative instability test, Lysholm: 96.6
2017 Mitchell et al. III USA 49 30.4 The Opteform allograft bone 3.1 years Failure rate: 6.1%, Lysholm: 77
2018 Diermeier et al. III Germany 44 30.5 Iliac autobone 33.9 months Lysholm: 77.2, IKDC: 69.0, Tegner: 4.1
  1. Values are presented as number only, mean standard deviation, or mean only
  2. F/U Follow-up, NA Not available, IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee